The ‘Unrateables’

I know there is great debate within the blogosphere on the posting of negative reviews. Personally, I choose not to. I’d prefer to spend my time writing about books I enjoyed and sharing the book love.

However, that sometimes leaves me with a bit of a ‘grey area’, with books I like to think of as ‘Unrateables’. (This is not, I promise, a back-handed compliment!)

You see, another thing I see quite often (on twitter and the like) are children’s books being given rubbish reviews (on a****n, goodreads etc) because “it’s childish” or “it’s ok for kids”…well, um, yeah…its a *children’s* book.

Which leads me to my quandary (we got there in the end), which is that usually when I read the kids books I choose to read (MG for the most part) I love them as me, an adult.

However, sometimes I read books that I didn’t particularly fall in love with, but that I know are absolutely spot on for their intended audience (kids) and wouldn’t hesitate to recommend at work etc to young readers.

Books that are well pitched and written for that age. Books that often tackle thorny subjects or feelings incredibly well and at just the right level. Books that balance serious stories with humour or fantasy or a pinch of the unlikely. But books that don’t grab me on a personal level.

Today’s books are two like this. The Boy at The Back of the Class by Onjali Q. Rauf and The Closest Thing to Flying by Gill Lewis.

There used to be an empty chair at the back of my class, but now a new boy called Ahmet is sitting in it.

He never talks and never smiles and doesn’t like sweets.

But then I learned the truth: Ahmet really isn’t very strange at all. He’s a refugee who’s run away from a War. And the more I find out about him, the more I want to help.

This book is a great way of opening up discussion about war, refugees and – more generally – differences, prejudices, fairness, right and wrong.

I thought the way we were introduced to Ahmet, and the way we see his integration into the classroom and relationships with others unfold was brilliantly written and paced.

Ahmet’s situation is described perfectly – there are some very difficult themes written about, but all are addressed sensitively and age-appropriately, and the author uses small, everyday things to really make it understandable and bring the message home (I thought the pomegranate storyline was lovely).

Likewise, the bullies at school not only introduce another, likely more familiar issue, but also cleverly highlights both how refugees are treated and mirrors the larger issues in the book.

A book which makes helping others – against the odds, in the face of obstacles and when we have no real reason to – seem obvious.

With strong themes of friendship and loyalty, and including a fast-paced, very funny adventure, this takes on some heartbreaking issues but with humour and a heart-warming touch.

Present day: Semira and her mother were brought to England by a man who has complete control. Always moving on, always afraid of being caught, she longs for freedom.

1891: Hen’s trapped in a life of behaving like a lady. But her Aunt Kitty is opening her eyes to a whole new world. A world of animal rights, and votes for women, and riding bicycles!

When Semira discovers Hen’s diary, she finds the inspiration to be brave and to fight for her place in the world.

Semira and her mum have had to flee their country, and the way not just this but the surrounding issues – the reasons they fled, the way they had to do it, the control and power someone else now has over them, the constant moving – are explored sensitively and age-appropriately.

This Victorian narrative – that we see through Hen’s diary, found by Semira – likewise highlights issues of that time too, not least some very sexist and prejudiced attitudes, but also the very beginnings of change and a glimmer of hope.

The use of birds and cycling to draw parallels between the two times, and between the characters really drew them together as well as creating powerful metaphors for the feelings of being trapped and free was very cleverly done. And of course, there was the link between Semira and Hen. Both feeling trapped and powerless, both find the courage to do something about it – Hen drawing on the spirit of her Aunt Kitty and friends, Semira on turn drawing on Hen.

Another thing I thought was very clever about the telling of Semira’s story was the way it drew on things both good and bad – ice cream, cycling, birds and homework; being an outsider, domestic abuse and bullying – that helped draw the characters together in spite of outward differences, and which in turn will help readers from all backgrounds relate to, empathise with and understand them.

Empowering and inspiring, this is a book filled with brave, determined and strong female characters. It is a book of solidarity, trust and friendship. It is a book about helping others, but also allowing others to help you. It is a book about standing up for your beliefs and for each other. It is a book full of hope, power and action in the face of adversity. It is a book about finally flying free.


15 thoughts on “The ‘Unrateables’

  1. I prefer not to write negative reviews either- the lowest is 3 stars. I do rate them on Goodreads though (very rare! Only thing I’ve given below a three this year so far is Yerma, which I had to read for school and despised)
    I really enjoyed the Boy at the Back of the Class when I read it, and have The Closest Thing to Flying on my TBR as you know ๐Ÿ’œ
    Amy x

    Liked by 2 people

      • I’m looking forward to trying it ๐Ÿ˜Š. I’m sure you have no intention of reading, but highly highly recommend steering clear of Yerma ๐Ÿ˜‚. I’ve not hated a book so much for ages (I won’t name the last one till I’ve had a sneaky check of your Goodreads because literally everyone loved it… except me)

        Liked by 1 person

      • I’m not surprised you’ve not heard of it tbf- it’s a Spanish play (I need to write about it and another play called Bodas de Sangre for my folio soon). I think the writer is quite famous in Spain. The book was the Loneliest Girl in the Universe by Lauren James. All of my Goodreads friends bar one have it 5 stars ๐Ÿ˜‚

        Liked by 1 person

      • Haha, yes quite niche!
        No, not read that one – you know me and YA! I don’t mind a bit but don’t read much. Well, you can’t please everyone as they say!

        Liked by 1 person

      • Yes very niche ๐Ÿ˜‚. The one for French is a bit more mainstream as it got translated a few years ago (No et Moi). I liked it a bit more, though Yerma got just 1 star so I didn’t love it or anything…
        I should have guessed you wouldn’t have read It! I’d tell you not to read it, but I’m 100% the unpopular opinion so I’m sure you’d love it.x

        Liked by 1 person

  2. I donโ€™t write negative reviews on my blog- but sometimes I have to write critical reviews on Amazon because of being part of their review scheme- There Have been books in the past I have been harsh towards (grown up and childrenโ€™s), and I regret most of that but there are also books that Iโ€™ve probably been gentler to because I felt a connection or value to them.

    I agree with you on unrateables though, and some books are zeitgeisty or perfect for children but not necessarily for adult readers etc. I think I work on a largely emotional level though!!

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Pingback: Unrateables 2 – A Witch and a Mouse | Bellis Does Books

  4. Pingback: WWW Wednesday 4/9/19 | Bellis Does Books

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s